Pinterest Case Study Update: How I Achieved a 38% Increase in Earnings

By Spencer Haws |

A couple of days ago, I posted an update for an Adsense based site that I purchased.  Today, I am going to share the details of a second site that I purchased earlier in the year.

As you may recall, both of these sites are ones that I am using as “case study” sites.  I’ve shared the process of buying the sites, and I’ll be keeping the updates coming for the entire year or until I sell them off.

As explained in a previous post, the site I will be covering today is in the craft niche.  The site receives most of its traffic (nearly 3,000 visitors a day) from Pinterest.  I’ve also done some experiments with Facebook traffic that showed some promise, but I’m not going to be pursue that avenue for now as I’ll explain below.

Pinterest Site Review and Traffic Stats

So, lets jump right into it!  I purchased this site on Flippa for $2,100.  Before I bought the site, it was making about $200 per month.  However, this has been my “trouble” site, and I knew that going in.

A few of the issues the site had (I knew all of this before buying the site):

Now, lets take a look at what I’ve done to the site so far.

First, I wanted to see if I could start getting more natural search engine traffic from Google.  The site actually has great metrics, with a Page Authority over 40 and PageRank of 4.


So, I did some keyword research using Long Tail Pro and found several low competition keywords in the niche.  I decided to start with just 1 keyword, write up an original content and see what would happen.  I only used internal linking from my own site to that article. (I was hoping the strength of the domain and internal links would be enough to get the article at least somewhere in the SERPs).

Unfortunately after a month, that article is still not ranking anywhere.  This either confirms my suspicion that Google is not going to rank content on this site (because most of it is copied/curated content); or that I need to build external links.  For now, this site simply does not make enough money to pursue too many tactics.

So, I’m leaving the organic traffic question alone for now and focusing on other tactics.

Here’s what the traffic to the site looks like for March (as of March 26th):

Click to Enlarge

The traffic continues to remain great.  In order to sustain this traffic, I am paying someone a couple of bucks an article to curate a few articles each week and then pinning images to Pinterest.

Here’s the source breakdown of all the traffic:


So, you can see that I DO get some organic search traffic, but I believe its a bit deceiving.  I’m pretty sure that most of that “organic” traffic is really from image searches on Google (my site has alot of images).

And here is a breakdown of the social traffic:


Clearly Pinterest dominates.

As mentioned, I did an experiment on Facebook where essentially I just started posting existing articles from my site on Facebook (the site already had over 3,000 FB fans).  As you can see from my previous report, this did indeed send some traffic.

Want To Build Smart & Relevant Internal Links...Quickly?

NichePursuits Rating

Link Whisper is a revolutionary tool that makes internal linking much faster, easier, and more effective.  It makes it simple to boost your site’s authority in the eyes of Google. You can use Link Whisper to:

  • Bring out your orphaned content that isn’t ranking
  • Create smart, relevant, and fast internal links
  • Simple yet effective internal links reporting: what has lots of links and what pages need more links? 

Click here to revolutionize your site’s way of doing internal links

Build better internal links with Link Whisper

However, the amount of traffic is not anywhere close to what Pinterest is sending, and it was taking about the same amount of effort.  So, I’ve decided to just let it ride with Pinterest.

March Earnings – Big Increase!

I made the gamble with this site knowing that it was banned from Google Adsense.  Unfortunately, it doesn’t look like Adsense is going to let this site get back in with all the copied content.  With Adsense, I could double the earnings of this site overnight.  Unfortunately, that’s not an option, so I’m using as an alternative.

In February, this site earned $179.62 from ads, and another $20 or so from Infolinks and Kontera ads.  So, the total earnings of the site was approximately $200 for the month of February.  So, it was earning almost exactly the same as what it did before I bought the site; which is fine.

However, in March (actually near end of Feb) I got a bit more aggressive with the ads.  After all, these are visitors from Pinterest just looking for pictures.  If you don’t hit them with ads in the first 30 seconds they will be gone.  So, I basically just started using the largest ad size available on, the 600×250 unit.


I’m now using one of these large ads near the top of my post and one in the middle.  As a result, my earnings have improved!

Earnings Graph from

So far during March (through March 26th), the earnings are – $201.68.  (That would be $240.46 on a prorated basis for March)

So far (again March 26th) the site has earned $19.54 from Kontera ads. (This would be $23.30 on a prorated basis).

The site also has InfoLinks Earnings of $9.51 (or $11.34 on a prorated basis).

So, overall the site has already earned $230.73 this month, and should earn close to $275.10 for the entire month of March!

I know we are not talking huge numbers here, but a 38% increase (from $200 to $275) in earnings is pretty good!  Overall, I’m very happy with the progress the site has made so far.

Plans Going Forward – Build an Email List

Despite the increase in earnings, I’m not satisfied.  With 3,000 visitors per day, I feel like I should be able to monetize them better.

So, I’m in the process of getting an opt-in form in place on my site to start collecting emails.  Once I actually start seeing some people join my email list, I’ll then dig in and write up an emails series that includes some affiliate offers or eventually sells my own ebook (or something).

To generate email leads, I’m giving away a free ebook that I picked up on  This site allows you to buy ebooks that have already been written, but gives you full control over rebranding or selling as your own if you want.

Overall, the progress has been good for this site; but I’m really hoping to dial in my opt in forms and eventually email funnel to see if I can really increase the value of all the visitors to this site.  So, be on the lookout for my next update on this Pinterest site!

If you have any comments or questions, feel free to leave your thoughts below.  I look forward to the discussion.

Stories & Projects | 57 comments

By Spencer Haws

Spencer Haws is the founder of After getting a degree in Business Finance from BYU (2002) and an MBA from ASU (2007) he worked for 8 years in Business Banking and Finance at both Merril Lynch and Wells Fargo Bank.

While consulting with other small business owners as a business banker, Spencer finally had the desire to start his own business. He successfully built a portfolio of niche sites using SEO and online marketing that allowed him to quit his job in 2011. Since then he's been involved in dozens of online business ventures including: creating and exiting Long Tail Pro, running an Amazon FBA business for over 3 years and selling that business, founding, and co-founding You can learn more about Spencer here.

Want to learn step-by-step how I built my Niche Site Empire up to a full-time income?

Yes! I Love to Learn

You may also like

View all




Going “Google free” would have been crazy 5 years ago, but now it actually sounds viable thanks to new players like Pinterest.

I get a tiny trickle of traffic from the 50 or so pins I’ve created from my sites, but it’s hardly anything compared to what search brings in. Standing out as a newcomer to Pinterest has been a challenge (I’ve only been on it about two months).

You’ve said the site has around 1,500 articles – does that translate to 1,500+ pins from the site?

Spencer Haws

Mandi, each article has a few images on them, so while I don’t know the total number of pins on pinterest, I’m sure its at least 3 x 1,500 articles.

Adam Finan

Hey Spencer,
I have a few questions regarding the Pinterest traffic…

Are the pins from the websites own images or ripped from the internet/ creative commons?

Do you have to pin the images in each new article for it to generate traffic via Pinterest? – to get the images on boards and in front of people. This sounds like a VA task…

Did you buy the Pinterest account + how many followers did it have?

Are you trying to grow your Pinterest following and how?


Spencer Haws

We pin all the images from our articles on pinterest. This is definitely something a VA is doing for me. When I bought the site it came with the pinterest account and Facebook page – so yes, I bought the pinterest account. It has around 300 followers. I’m not doing anything to grow my following other than pinning images from the articles.


Are there any strategies or tactics you’re using for boosting pinterest traffic? Or has it been a function of pinning a lot of images over time?

Spencer Haws

Just pinning images over time.


Hey Spencer!

I’m happy to see your increase in earnings!

Recently, I’ve built my own site, which gets traffic from social sites, mainly from Facebook. It has been running almost a month now and thanks to one post which went viral it got almost 30k visitors! 🙂

I have the same desire to “catch” these visitors, but instead of trying them to sub to my e-mail list (I have none) I want them to like my Facebook page.

My strategy is really aggressive – In the right sidebar there is huge FB Like Box with stream so they can see it is not dead page, then when you scroll down there is flyout (WP plugin called “End Page Slide Box”) which comes from left side with another (smaller) like box, saying something like “Like our page, you won’t regret it!”, and another like button under each post. Last chance to get like is provided by Exit-Popup which appears when visitor hover over the top of page, saying “Before you leave…” with another like box (This isn’t that annoying Popup which won’t let you leave, it just gets your attention one last time, it’s made by member of BHW forum and it’s free, let me know if you want link 🙂 )

I don’t know how to measure what converts the best, but I’m getting quite a nice amount of fans each day 🙂 So maybe some of this could help you with your e-mail list!

Anyway, thanks for update! Keep it up!

Spencer Haws

Thanks for sharing the opt in tips…I definitely have some plans to get more agressive as I dial in my funnel, etc. I will just say that you might want to be careful about putting all your eggs in the facebook basket. An email list is MUCH better than facebook fans. You don’t really own your fans, and facebook is making it harder and harder to actually connect with your fans anyway. With email, you do own that list and can reach your audience at will. However, nothing wrong with having the facebook fans as well – ideally you can have both.


I see your point and you are totally right. Although my site is like Viral Nova or other website with fun/interesting posts (but in my language) so I think people don’t care that much about that, you know. They will like my FB page so that something insteresting might appear on their news feed and that’s it.

However, when it comes to hobbies and more specific interests (like your site) then it’s definitely worth to build your community outside of FB. 100% agree 🙂


Hi Jenda, You are aware that FB is slashing visibility of pages ? Only around 2%-4% of your fans are going to see your posts and it’s only going to get worse so email list is a must.



Nice to see you stick and move…..

Taking on these challenging cases will only make you a much more skilled IM’er.

You and I discussed my experiment utilizing case studies in the FB mastermind groups to drive traffic to my new blog.

The blog is only weeks old and has close to 3,000 page views and about 700 uniques, with almost zero bounce rate.

I took your advice and started building my list within days of starting.

Massman in Boston

Spencer Haws

Awesome…and great to see the early success with social traffic…hope it continues for you!


Nice! Really appreciate the tip about the ebook.

One of my own niche sites has recently picked up a few thousand visits per month from Pinterest, so I’ve added opt-in forms on it to build a list.

The optin form currently doesn’t offer a freebie. But I could grab an ebook from that site for much cheaper than hiring a quality writer.


Richard Johnson

Another thank you for the tip on the e-book site. Also, congratulations on the increase of revenue. A 30%+ increase is awesome.

Spencer Haws

No problem…thanks Richard!


Hello Spencer.

Do you host this website on HostGator? What is your monthly used bandwidth?

Spencer Haws

I’d have to check to see what the bandwidth is….


Hi Spencer,

Congrats on the huge increase. 30% increase in a short span of time is awesome. And the free ebook from gives me another idea to increase my income for my affiliate sites.

Keep this kind of posts coming. We are glad you show us the full stats for your niche sites.

Spencer Haws

Thanks Jeffrey!


Too bad you can’t slide under the line like Viral Nova and still get Adsense. So unfairs.

What about running those spammy ads like “one weird secret?” Maybe some CPA’s or something.

I hear you on the email list. I have 2 sites right now that just send traffic to Amazon, and It seems like such a waste to have 1,000 visitors a day flow throwing a site for a one-time purchase.

Email has always scared me for some reason. But I plan on getting it fully implemented on these two sites. Probably going to try to start with a 5-day autoresponder series to get them to purchase a clickbank product. Not sure what to sell them after that.

Spencer Haws

Nah, I don’t like the spammy ads :(. Good luck with the autoresponder!


Thanks for sharing that free ebook giveaway idea! I’m a bit confused though., I took a look at that site you mentioned. to buy an ebook (Master resale and what’s unclear to me is,…

Must i buy every copy from them i plan to give away?


Is it a 1 time purchase after which i can freely give them away a much as i want?

1th option seems expensive, 2nd option seems to good to be true,….

I’m totaly new to ebooks and/or building an email list so i have no idea how these things work yet,….

Spencer Haws

You buy one copy and you can use it as much as you want. You are buying the master resale rights. Super cheap.


Good news 🙂

Thanks Spencer..


Pinterest takes a lot of micro-managing if you aren’t using a bot. Congrats on the earnings increase! Looking forward to seeing your plans to increase the social traffic.

stephen aidoo

spencer this is great. one point is google is not the only way to monitize a site. and it a good news for anyone who’s site is banned by google. and so far as google dominate they will always make the rules. but outside google is a new rule. One can even monitize a site through curated contents. WOW

One thing i think we should look up to is how to generate more traffic through pinterest. is there a process to get more people through pinterest? i think this can even be an article on it own. what do you think.

Spencer Haws

We just pin lots of images.


Hi Spencer.
I’m interested to know, when building email lists for your sites, do you build then all under one aweber account ( or other provider)? Or do you set up new accounts for each site / niche? The disadvantage I can imagine to having them under one account is that by unsubscribing can’t those people have an option to unsubscribe from all your lists and therefore see all your lists / niches?
Cheers, Fran

Spencer Haws

Under one Aweber account. No, I don’t think they see other lists when unsubscribing; even if they did, it wouldn’t matter. I don’t care if they see my other lists/niches.

Beauty Lix

social traffic has a big bounce rate, i really do not know how to fix it

[email protected] de lit

I’m happy to see your increase in earnings!


Hey Spencer!

I agree this blog could convert better, but at the same time (beside some profit) you are making a great reserach on what monetization method work for such site and what doesn’t work at all.

I just sold my Pinterest site for aprox. $5000. It brought me almost $700 per month via Adsense. It will be very interesting to see how my buyer will prosper with it, since he doesn’t have Adsense acct. anymore.

Spencer Haws

Interesting. Without adsense it will be tough for the new buyer most likely.

Mark Sagent

Great post Spencer and congrats on your new website!

I just finished your video series with Perrin (Project 2) and looking forward to see your progress with this site.

I really appreciate all the tips that you share along the way.

Best of luck.

Mark Sagent (aka Salespro)

Spencer Haws

Thanks Mark!


Thanks again Spencer for sharing all this valuable info, so appreciated.

Daniel [email protected] automatique

I’m happy to see your increase in earnings!thanks lot 🙂


Thanks for ebook tip Spencer. Definitely going to check it out. I always love your posts and the inside scoop on how you manage your sites. This Pinterest site has great traffic. Hope you can monetize it more!

Mr. Pennyworth

Great post. I’m going to have to try and start utilizing Pinterest for traffic.

Also I just subscribed to your newsletter. This site is awesome and I’m trying to use your advice to build my own little niche site.


Great work. That was amazing number of traffic from pinterest and congrats for your new site. 🙂


Hi Spencer – Do you use group boards for pinning or are you only pinning to your account ? Pinning to group boards can dramatically increase your traffic although it is much much harder to get into group boards nowadays in Pinterest.

One thing to worry about in Pinterest is that they are very quick in disabling accounts due to the amount of spammers that they have so it’s best to build a backup account if you can.

I’ve been using Pinterest for than a year – you can shoot me an email if you have any question. I will be glad to share information as I’ve learned a lot from you !

Spencer Haws

I’m just pinning to my own account right now.


Hi Spencer, great post & update, once again!

Spencer Turner

Hey Spencer, great to read that you’re having success via Pinterest. I can’t believe how much traffic it is generating!

One of my Pinterest accounts has close to 8,000 followers and thousands of repins but I don’t get anywhere near the amount of traffic you are. On my account all of the pics are linked to their destination / post page and also a url to the destination is included in the description to try to maximize CTR, what trickery are you using to to get so much traffic lol?!

Spencer Haws

Honestly I have no idea! The site was getting this much traffic before I bought it from Pinterest, and it still does. I think perhaps its just the niche I’m in that gets lots of repins, etc.

John J. ZIemba

Hey Spencer

Perfect timing on this post. I have just started using social media to promote my World Hottest Hot Sauce site. I can see FBs potential and I definitely will be checking out content posting options there. Haven’t tried Pinterest yet, and have no idea what pins are, but that’s the next one I’m headed for.

Thx for your shared knowledge. Sure helps a
great deal.


Hello, Thank you for your post. I got approved by and then added ad units to my wordpress twenty twelve theme, but for some reason my ads are nor showing correctly, they just go all the way down my footer. I changed sizes and locations, but still having same problem. I would really appreciate if you could review my site – the-gorod com
Thank you very much


Hi Spencer! I’ve been slow to jump on the Pinterest bandwagon but this post definitely inspired me to move forward. Thanks for the tips! I usually do twitter, linkedin and facebook but I decided to try pinterest. I really do wonder what everyone else is doing to get tons of traffic from Pinterest? well I found the answers here but Gosh it would be nice to pin this but no image in the post 🙁


Very Nice Articels Sir, God Job keep It Up 🙂

Tonya D

This post was very helpful!

I’ve been following your blog for a few months, and this is the first time I’ve added a comment.

I have a website that gets mainly Pinterest traffic and the niche is interior design and decorating, and the posts are mainly curated. I’m still struggling to get my traffic up, but you’ve given me some ideas here.

Thanks again 🙂


Hi Spencer,

I’m thinking of buying an expired domain for a new e-commerce site I’m about to launch. The expired domain is from the same niche, but it was strictly a blog in the past. Obviously, my e-commerce site will also include a blog, so there will be some continuity. Will google penalize me if I convert the site from a blog to an e-commerce site, or am I fine as long as its all within the same niche?

Spencer Haws

First make sure that the previous site was not spammy, etc. If its a clean domain, then you should be fine.

[email protected] portable samsung

I’m happy to see your increase in earnings

[email protected] sans fil

I’m happy to see your increase in earnings!

[email protected] photo canon

I’m happy to see your increase in earnings!


Hi Spencer,

When I read about this site I thought you were talking about my site. I have a site, not the one I listed in this profile that I bought on flippa, at the time I had no clue what I was doing and I paid WAY too much for the site.

Anyway I was getting about 4000 uniques a day from pinterest, the site was 100% scraped images, not 1 word of text, like I said I was clueless… It was using Adsense and making about 100/day. I made changes to the design, ad placement etc and got it to where it was making 200+ a day… Then google came a knocking and disabled the ads, I thought I was lucky they didn’t ban me/ I had chat support and they guy just said you have no written content. So I hired writers, wrote about 10 articles, then wrote a couple hundred descriptions for various images of 50 words each and I reapplied, they did a manual review and put the ads back on my site. So I went from 150-220 a day, to zero, then when I came back I could never get it back to that level, the CPC was half, so I think they flagged the site and reduced the rate they gave it. But as you can attest to, when you lose google and get it back you are happy so I was happy to be back making about 100 a day… then… BOOM…. 2 weeks ago Pinterest blocked my site completely I have hundreds of thousands of links on pinterest, if you click on one of my links now it just says site blocked due to spam. The guy I bought the site from spammed it heavily and had an account with 120K pins, many of those have been repinned thousands of times. I don’t spam at all but I guess some competitors complained I was spamming and they blocked me. Like your site I get some traffic from google but 95% was pinterest and it is gone, today the site made 5$. So from 210 to 5$/day in about 6 months time. In the end the hard lesson is one you know of and speak of often and that is you can never be safe with one main source or traffic or monetization… I am starting some other sites and trying to learn from your lessons on here… Keep up the good work.

PS I went to rank hero and submitted a question because I think I need the service, is it still operating, I haven’t heard from anyone. It has been about 24 hours so I guess they could be busy

Thanks again for all the great info, your story of your pinterest site just made me have to comment.

Spencer Haws

Wow, thanks for sharing your story. I don’t have much experience with Pinterest, but doesn’t surprise me that this could happen. Also a good heads up for others entering the market. Thanks, and best of luck.

Recent Posts

View all